Repair or Replace My Car?

Big repair quote? Compare what it really costs to keep your car against buying another one over the same stretch of time.

Keep your current car

Replace it

Your driving

Cost to keep current car: -

Cost to replace: -

Monthly payment on replacement: -

Repair quote vs car value: -

Verdict: -

Estimate only. Trade-in assumes you sell the current car unrepaired for its value minus the repair cost. Any loan balance left at the end and the replacement's resale value aren't counted. Get a second repair quote before deciding.

Make the car you keep last longer

Whichever way you go, regular maintenance is what keeps the next big bill away. The Vehicle Maintenance Log & Car Records Kit tracks every service for up to 5 vehicles, flags what's DUE SOON or OVERDUE, and keeps the records that help you sell for more. Excel + Google Sheets + printables.

Get the Vehicle Maintenance Log ($5.99)

Common questions

Should I repair or replace my car?

A common rule of thumb: if a repair costs more than the car is worth, or more than about a year of payments on a replacement, replacing usually makes more sense. If the car is otherwise reliable and paid off, one big repair is often still cheaper than a new car payment.

What is the 50 percent rule for car repairs?

Some people replace a car once a single repair costs more than half of what the car is worth. It's a quick gut check, not a hard rule. Look at the total cost of keeping the car over the next year or two, not just this one bill.

Related: true cost per mile · next oil change · maintenance schedule by mileage

More free tools: all calculators · eBay fees · Poshmark/Mercari fees · shop labor rate · quarterly 1099 tax · cost per mile · MPG & gas cost · oil change due · repair or replace